Hard question. I love both of them… But I think I’d prefer wind waker.
Pauricc9
Wind waker and it’s not even close
Psychoville93
Twilight Princess 100%, it was my first Zelda game.
Jumpy_Ad9575
Wind Waker for sure!
Cmdrdredd
I much preferred Twilight Princess because I found the sailing around to be boring in wind waker. Most of the rest of the game was fine but that dragged it down for me.
Im-Mr-Bulldopz
The music, the art style, the SAILING!
Wind Waker is as charming as it is fun and it’s one of the more memorable experiences I’ve had with a Zelda game.
HungryNoodle
Wind waker by far.
Only_Commission_7929
If you want a “traditional” Zelda experience, Twilight.
If you want the most memorable experience, WindWaker.
Djikstra_Is_Cool
Wind Waker 7 days a week, no offense to Twilight Princess but it’s no competition
ZeroFutue
Wind Waker is better and more memorable. Looks better as well.
IneiTheDark
Twilight Princess all the way. Gloomy atmosphere and wolf link!
OverdressedShingler
Wind Waker for me, hands down. My favourite game of all time. It was the first Zelda I properly played.
Triltaison
Twilight Princess. Love the Arbiter’s Grounds boss fight.
CosmicOwl47
Ah they’re both so good and so different from each other.
I’d have to choose WW just because it was the first Zelda I played.
ericbana19
Twilight Princess
kruvik
Twilight Princess for me.
Radius_314
Twilight Princess. No contest.
Peripheral1994
Wind Waker for exactly one precise reason: I’m mega arachnophobic, and having a Skulltula-less Zelda game to enjoy is a godsend.
dasaigaijin
TP is my least favorite Zelda game (doesn’t mean I don’t like it though) I just didn’t like the animation art style and the music and sound effects always made me sleepy.
Wind Waker was much more vibrant and memorable.
SunkenTemple
WindWaker. Haven’t played TwilightPrincess, but I’ve seen it, and I like WW style better. Personal preference, I’m sure both games are great.
Hannis222
Definitely “Wind Waker”! Graphics are timeless!
Leramar89
Wind Waker.
Venom3386
Yes.
SQunX
twilight princess
phara-normal
Wind Waker.
I like both but Wind Wakers art style is holding up way better. Personally I also enjoy the nautical setting and vibes way more than the edgyness of Twilight Princess.
Edit: Thinking about it, maybe I actually don’t really like TP, I certainly wouldn’t go back to replay it but have done so with WW. I think the complete 180 in tone they did for TP was way too much. I know fans wanted the series to grow up but I think they did the opposite, now as an adult I find WW to be the much more mature game.
IceFrostwind
Meat and Potatoes of Windwaker, Dessert of Twilight Princess.
Turbantastic
Twilight princess, the only thing that lets the game down was those annoying wolf sections collecting the bugs. Just a pain in the arse forcing yourself through to enjoy the rest of the game!
Krail
Wind Waker is one of my favorite games. It’s art style still holds up today, and the whole game just has this really nice feel to it. Everything has this really smooth, punchy feel. It helps that I actually kind of enjoy the sailing.
It also has one of the best endings in the series, and the setting for the final boss fight might be my favorite dramatic setpiece in any game.
lRainZz
Wind Waker. Loved both games, but twilight Princess was way too dark/gloomy for my liking.
ComplexxToxin
You people are INSANE. Wind Waker is GOAT.
Furry_Lover_Umbasa
Both is good
scharmlippe
Windwaker but twilight princess is very close
Gold-Mug
Only a sith deals in absolutes.
piichan14
Visually, WW. TP went with the brown poop color palette that a lot of games had during that time.
Gameplay wise, I say both.
TheSbocKxD
Wind Waker is a better game. Twilight Princess has more story and a better villain but overall it’s not as polished as Wind Waker.
Station111111111
It’s a crime that Windwaker is not on Switch. I love that game.
Infernous-NS
Twilight Princess has always been my favorite Zelda game. Grew up watching Lord of the Rings and other fantasy movies like it, and Twilight Princess was always the closest in terms of realism, story, and atmosphere to that cinematic experience.
Patutula
I liked both but if I had to choose ->Wind Waker. It was magical.
sylva748
Twilight Princess for me. But Wind Walker is also such a great game i can easily see why people choose it.
DerPicasso
Ive never gotten into Twilight Princess, dunno why. Tried on gc and wii.
40 Comments
Hard question. I love both of them… But I think I’d prefer wind waker.
Wind waker and it’s not even close
Twilight Princess 100%, it was my first Zelda game.
Wind Waker for sure!
I much preferred Twilight Princess because I found the sailing around to be boring in wind waker. Most of the rest of the game was fine but that dragged it down for me.
The music, the art style, the SAILING!
Wind Waker is as charming as it is fun and it’s one of the more memorable experiences I’ve had with a Zelda game.
Wind waker by far.
If you want a “traditional” Zelda experience, Twilight.
If you want the most memorable experience, WindWaker.
Wind Waker 7 days a week, no offense to Twilight Princess but it’s no competition
Wind Waker is better and more memorable. Looks better as well.
Twilight Princess all the way.
Gloomy atmosphere and wolf link!
Wind Waker for me, hands down. My favourite game of all time. It was the first Zelda I properly played.
Twilight Princess. Love the Arbiter’s Grounds boss fight.
Ah they’re both so good and so different from each other.
I’d have to choose WW just because it was the first Zelda I played.
Twilight Princess
Twilight Princess for me.
Twilight Princess. No contest.
Wind Waker for exactly one precise reason: I’m mega arachnophobic, and having a Skulltula-less Zelda game to enjoy is a godsend.
TP is my least favorite Zelda game (doesn’t mean I don’t like it though) I just didn’t like the animation art style and the music and sound effects always made me sleepy.
Wind Waker was much more vibrant and memorable.
WindWaker.
Haven’t played TwilightPrincess, but I’ve seen it, and I like WW style better. Personal preference, I’m sure both games are great.
Definitely “Wind Waker”! Graphics are timeless!
Wind Waker.
Yes.
twilight princess
Wind Waker.
I like both but Wind Wakers art style is holding up way better. Personally I also enjoy the nautical setting and vibes way more than the edgyness of Twilight Princess.
Edit: Thinking about it, maybe I actually don’t really like TP, I certainly wouldn’t go back to replay it but have done so with WW. I think the complete 180 in tone they did for TP was way too much. I know fans wanted the series to grow up but I think they did the opposite, now as an adult I find WW to be the much more mature game.
Meat and Potatoes of Windwaker, Dessert of Twilight Princess.
Twilight princess, the only thing that lets the game down was those annoying wolf sections collecting the bugs. Just a pain in the arse forcing yourself through to enjoy the rest of the game!
Wind Waker is one of my favorite games. It’s art style still holds up today, and the whole game just has this really nice feel to it. Everything has this really smooth, punchy feel. It helps that I actually kind of enjoy the sailing.
It also has one of the best endings in the series, and the setting for the final boss fight might be my favorite dramatic setpiece in any game.
Wind Waker.
Loved both games, but twilight Princess was way too dark/gloomy for my liking.
You people are INSANE. Wind Waker is GOAT.
Both is good
Windwaker but twilight princess is very close
Only a sith deals in absolutes.
Visually, WW. TP went with the brown poop color palette that a lot of games had during that time.
Gameplay wise, I say both.
Wind Waker is a better game. Twilight Princess has more story and a better villain but overall it’s not as polished as Wind Waker.
It’s a crime that Windwaker is not on Switch. I love that game.
Twilight Princess has always been my favorite Zelda game. Grew up watching Lord of the Rings and other fantasy movies like it, and Twilight Princess was always the closest in terms of realism, story, and atmosphere to that cinematic experience.
I liked both but if I had to choose ->Wind Waker. It was magical.
Twilight Princess for me. But Wind Walker is also such a great game i can easily see why people choose it.
Ive never gotten into Twilight Princess, dunno why. Tried on gc and wii.